AHAR to Allsorts

Since the introduction of the EU Legislation the Balai Directive 92/65/EEC in 2012 (enforced by the UK Government in 31^st December 2013) it has been a legal requirement for all EU Member states to comply when importing/exporting puppies and dogs as trade from one European country to another.   Dog breeders and rescues are both classified as TRADE as defined by the movement of animals between one member state to another.

All premises exporting puppies and dogs must be registered under Balai, Article 4 of Council Directive 92/65/EEC. All dogs, puppies must have a microchip, vaccinated against rabies (puppies must be 12 weeks of age) and have a valid Passport.   A private Veterinary Practitioner must examine all dogs and puppies 48 hours prior to transport to confirm that he/she has inspected the dogs/puppies and found them in good health and fit to travel and a Balai Health Certificate can be issued.  The puppies and dogs must wait for 21 days (day of rabies vaccination is not counted, therefore 22 days), until able to be exported.  Puppies must be at least 15 weeks of age before leaving their country of birth.  

An EU Intra Trade Certificate must be completed and the details entered into TRACES.  All dogs and puppies must be exported in accordance with Directive 1/2005. The recipient at the destination named on the certification must notify their local APHA office at least 24 hours prior to the expected arrival of the consignment of puppies or dogs to enable their paperwork to be inspected by their local APHA officer.

I am very critical of rescues and dog breeders that have not complied with the EU Legislation when exporting/importing dogs and puppies, to not comply results in a lack of traceability of exported dogs and puppies should a Rabies outbreak occur in the UK?

For some rescues this appears too difficult to comprehend and they have taken the risk of exporting dogs to the UK illegally.  One such rescue was AHAR, who in 2013 were transporting dogs in loose cages in a cattle truck, which is illegal. They vehemently denied my allegations of smuggling dogs which they did from 2012 until at least up to February 2015.  Then in January 2015 AHARs premises were Registered under Balai,  whether they succumbed to pressure, took the initiative and decided to Register and operate legally or whether this was forced onto them by a Government Department is not clear but  AHAR at Crag, Castleisland, Kerry is now registered under Balai to export dogs.

However with Registration comes responsibility AHAR has to agree to comply with certain conditions under Council Directive 92/65 (Balai Directive).

A private vet must be engaged to ensure the day to compliance with the requirements of the Directive.

They must have dogs and cat’s resident on the premises examined regularly by a private vet in accordance with Article 3 (3) of Directive 90/425/EEC.

Comply with any measures required by the Department of Agriculture, Food and Marine to carry out monitoring or surveillance for animal disease.

Place on the market for trade, only dogs which show no sign of disease and only at a time when the holding and area in which they are located is not subject to health restrictions.

Ensure that the welfare of the dogs are complied with.

Failure to comply with any of the above conditions will result in the Balai Registration being revoked.

As AHAR export hundreds of dogs a year to the UK.  TRACES show that 36 consignments of a total of 424 dogs were exported from AHAR during the period January 2015 to November 2015.  Registration should be very important for AHAR to ensure they can continue to export dogs legally to the UK and do not take any risks to lose their Registration.   To do so would make it difficult for them to revert back to prior 2015, when they were operating their exporting of dogs illegally.   Too many eyes would be on their activities now and are aware of their transports.

AHAR is the main supplier of rescue dogs to Allsorts Dog Rescue in West Sussex.  The number of dogs  legally exported  from 17^th February 2015 until 9^th December 2015 to Allsorts were 414 dogs there have been further imports since the 9^th until end of December 2015 possibly another 10 dogs so around 424 dogs in total.   Adoption charges at Allsorts are £150 to £200 per dog resulting in a healthy turnover in the region of £70,596 to £94,128 per annum less their expenses.   Allsorts Dog Rescue refer to their rescue as a non-profit organisation, whatever that means, they are not officially registered with either the Charities Commission or Companies House so can only be described as a business.  

With AHAR and Allsorts now compliant with Balai I did not expect to see dogs arriving from AHAR to Allsorts less than their 22 days after rabies vaccination but hey ho, are they still trying to be sneaky?

Lottie and Ruple were from a litter of four puppies collected from Ballinasloe Horse Fair in the ROI on 17^th October 2015. Photos at AHAR show them being flea sprayed at their premises.  On the 7^th November 2015 two were displayed on Allsorts web site alongside  the other dogs arrived from AHAR on the same consignment but Lottie was referred to as Lita. On the 9^th November both dogs reappeared but now called Lottie and Ruple.  Remembering that puppies must be rabies vaccinated no younger than 12 weeks of age and wait 22 days from the date of rabies vaccination before allowed to be transported.   I cannot imagine a vet would administer a rabies vaccination on the 17th a Saturday the day of arrival from the horse fair or Sunday. making  Monday the 19^th the earliest day possible.  22 days inclusive of the day of rabies vac brings the earliest day of transport to leave ROI as the 9^th of November 2015 but the consignment of dogs arrived with the others on the 7^th which was too early to be legally transported from AHAR in the ROI to the UK.   Allsorts must have realised their mistake of having put them on display on their web site too soon and removed their details and photos to be returned for display on the 9^th November the correct day they should have travelled and left AHAR in the ROI.    

 

Following on from this a dog referred to as Meg (below) posted on AHARs page on the 12^th December 2015 in their timeline photos that AHAR describe as an 8 year old yorkie x, female but a poster corrected AHAR on their Facebook page and said she was a Norfolk Terrier.  She was shown on Allsorts page on the 28^th December 2015 where she was described as a Norfolk terrier age 8 years, spayed and now called Yahtzee.  A poster wrote on Allsorts page that they  ‘saw this dog there last week’ indicating that she arrived on the same transport on the 23^rd December 2015 but was not displayed on Allsorts page until the 28^th December 2015.  Is this the same dog?  If so where are the 22 waiting days from date of rabies vaccination?  12^th December to 23^rd or even to the 28^th is not 22 days.

 

Then we have a white terrier (below) female spayed shown at AHAR on the 27th November and again after being spayed on the 14^th December 2015, this dog is shown again at Allsorts Dog Rescue on the 28^th December 2015 looking much cleaner, she is now called Monopoly.  If this is the same dog and it is believed to be, both dogs have the same white collar or is this just a coincidence?

What is going on ?  Do these dogs all have valid Passports, rabies vac, Balai certificate and were their details entered into TRACES?  I am aware that the majority of dogs have since February 2015 been compliant but have these ones?  If I am wrong then I apologise but if I am right then why are AHAR and Allsorts reverting back to old habits of under hand tactics and risking losing their Registration to export dogs legally?  It baffles me.     

 

Update: It has been requested by the photographer on behalf of Allsorts Dog Rescue that I remove the photos of the dogs at Allsorts Dog Rescue, reason given was for Copyright.  I accept that as a valid reason for removal.   

According to Allsorts Dog Rescue who has issued a statement (see below) my information is incorrect.  

Statement from Allsorts Dog Rescue

"We at Allsorts are clarifying that Patrica James is not looking back on the AHAR page far enough as she sees a picture of a dog and then assumes it has arrived that day!!!. From the link shown this dog arrived on the 27th of November 2015 and NOT the 14th of December 2015 as Patrica Jame's blog states."

The dog in question arrived at AHAR from the pound on the 27^th November 2015 (to clarify the above I did say on the Blog that I would apologize if I was wrong). However apart from the date being incorrect on the dogs’ arrival at AHAR all else is still questionable for the following reasons.

This dog arrived at AHAR from the pound along with others on Friday 27.11.2015

Between the 28^th Nov 2015 and 14^th Dec 2015 the dog was spayed. 

If this dog was operated on Monday 1^st Dec 2015 at the earliest as it would be inadvisable for a vet to operate on a dog so soon after coming from the pound with an unknown history. Most vets would advise 48 hours to elapse before spaying a dog from this situation due to stress. The normal routine would be a blood test prior to a major operation to ensure the dogs kidneys and liver are working well, both vital when dealing with anesthetic drugs. 

The question still arises when did this dog have her Rabies Vaccination?   Vets do not usually like to vaccinate a dog whilst under anesthesia as this can increase the risk of aspiration for the dog leading to vaccine failure because anesthetic agents can change the immune response to the vaccine.

The date of microchipping and rabies vaccination must be entered into the dogs Passport then a clear window of 22 days before the dog is allowed to be transported after being examined by a vet as fit to travel 24 hours before leaving AHAR and the details entered on a Balai Health Certificate and entered into TRACES. This dog along with others left AHAR on the 22^nd December 2015 arriving on the 23rd December at Allsorts Dog Rescue.

Was this dog was given his rabies vaccination at a very inappropriate time whilst undergoing a major operation or he was transported too soon to the UK?  Only a valid Passport and Balai Certificate would have proof of the date if applicable.

Many vets recommend that a Rabies vaccination is given to a dog a few weeks prior or after a major operation in case there is a reaction to either the vaccine or anesthesia if both administered at the same time.  Post-operative care is usually pain relief and  a lead walk only for 10/14 days after a spay before allowed to free run if the dog has external stitches as it is 10 days before removal.  What arrangements AHAR have for aftercare and if this is followed is debatable.

This is typical of many rescue dogs in the ROI arriving from the pound into rescue spayed, vaccinated and exported to the UK a very tight schedule and sometimes the 22 days are not met and the recipient rescue in the UK delays offering the dogs for adoption on their web site until the time is up for that reason.  This dog was not up for adoption until the 28^th December which of course could be due to the Christmas period or for other unknown reasons.

There is also another comment stating I am incorrect regarding the tan coloured dog the rescue is stating I am displaying the incorrect dog (see below) but how can that be, as the one I have shown is a female and the one the poster states as the correct dog is referred to as a male. That cannot be correct surely?  

Poster on behalf of Allsorts posted the link below stating it was the same dog as the second photo shown when at AHAR before groomed referred to as a 'he', meaning a male dog.   The one in photo (second photo) is a female at Allsorts called Meg at AHAR then Yahtzee at Allsorts shown in second photo above.       

Here 'facts' on the terrier also wrong. Note the date:

https://www.facebook.com/ahar.ie/photos/a.611288758890821.1073741849.145876848765350/1075217372497955/?type=3&__mref=message_bubble